Sunday, March 11, 2012

SAY HELLO, AND WAVE GOODBYE

Dear people I like, love and care for,

I started this blog as a reaction. I was accused of being two-faced for having questions, maybe not even believing like I once did. Since I wasn't letting people in on my personal struggles, I was accused of being deceitful, posing as a certain kind of Mormon, but really not being that person. That accusation hurt, so I reacted to it, went to the other side of the spectrum, and decided to be as open about myself as possible by starting this blog. I had no desire to be deceitful. My questions were personal, but in this world where people post every aspect of their life on Facebook, being personal is equated with lying. How sad.

My wife asked me an important question before I began posting on the blog. She asked me if I was trying to write in order to hurt the faith of others, or if I was writing to really be honest and present myself. I appreciate that question because I was in a painful place when I first started writing and I could have taken this blog in a different direction. I have tried to stay true to my original resolve that I am writing to express my questions and personal struggle with the intent to listen and interact with readers. Sometimes I fail. I apologize if I have. Of course, failure is a part of me, so even that is truthful.

Thus far on this blog I have described what others call my 'faith crisis'. This was something I described as a 'place without a name'. I've written about the pivotal theological struggle that brought me to my major doubt concerning LDS theology - the life of Eli and what our vicarious works say about God. The discussion that followed was a wonderful experience, but it made me see that I was not in a place to confirm the conservative LDS position represented by the comments of faithful LDS people. Nonetheless, I decided to continue to present, be honest, and explain my strife. So I kept writing: Mormons as Christians, Book of Mormon, Violence, Marriage, Polygamy, and The Book of Abraham. In each discussion I find myself on the other side of the aisle in respects to the LDS position.

Additionally, I started to become so distracted by these discussions that I lost track of studying and reading what really makes me happy. The posts with the most traffic and discussion are those focused on LDS issues, while what I really love - Jesus' parables - get little to no foot traffic. That's okay because I know that people are probably not that interested in reading notes on Dominic Crossan's insights to the parables of Jesus. But that's what I love. In short, I'm done with presenting the issues that brought me to my faith crisis and I want to get back to what I love.

I have a few drafts lined up for future posts revolving around LDS subjects: The First Vision, The Three Degrees of Glory, the Temples and Masons, and Trinitarian vs. LDS versions of the Godhead. But these topics have become more of a labor than an enjoyment. This blog is about opening myself up so that people can see what I struggle with in LDS theology and history. I've done that sufficiently. I'm ready to move on.

Say hello, and wave goodbye.

I wave goodbye to spending so much time on LDS issues that quite frankly, just make me angry and are draining. I wave goodbye to a church that helped me grow into who I am, and for that I am thankful. I wave goodbye to a church that thinks the world for 1800 years of history was void of God's authority to come unto Christ, despite the pleads of the people and the promise of God (Matt. 7:7-11; 16:18). I wave goodbye to the social pressure and cultural expectation of declaring 'I know' about everything to do with church, God, and scripture. I am no longer enchanted by the doctored history and theology presented at church, nor am I convinced that the LDS Church is a more accurate representation of the early Church or the teachings of Jesus than the rest of Christendom. I do not say this with the spirit of degrading Mormonism, simply to say, it’s time for me to move on. So, thank you for a good thirty years, fun youth dances, spiritual upliftment, direction, and wonderful people. Goodbye.

I'm saying hello to the parables, Church history and theology, Greek, unrestrained reading, acceptance of women as my equals in ministry, homosexuals as worthy children of God, and trained church leadership. I'm saying hello to an extremely challenging world that needs more bridges of acceptance than walls of doctrine, dogma, and worries over 'worthiness'. I even say hello to evolution. I am saying hello to a God I don't know, who is mysterious to my imperfect mind and I can admit that and think that's okay. I am saying hello to a faith greater than when I started, wherein the grace of God is more powerful than what I can ever do or not do. I'm saying hello to a Jewish peasant, who taught the Mosaic Law, proclaimed the kingdom, and died on the cross. I say hello to a hope, yes, a hope, that through that man we all can hope in the resurrection and the redemption of creation. Hello.

What do I do now? I continue to search, ponder and pray. I will continue to write on the blog. Sometimes the topic may be something to do with the LDS Church, but certainly not as frequently. I reiterate, I am not mad at the LDS Church. I thank it for the many positive aspects of its influence on my life. But this blog is about being honest and open. So here I am, and it's time for me to look forward in a new direction.

Say hello, and wave goodbye.

Search Ponder Pray Repeat

14 comments:

  1. Dear Travis,

    Good luck on your search. I wish you the best although I must admit, it amazes me to see how the more a person searches for something, the more lost he/she becomes. I, myself, looked unsuccessfully for God since a young age. After studying Catholicism, Jehovah Witnesses, Evangelists, Christians, and finally finding the Church of Christ (or Mormonism, as you title it), I gladly stopped looking. After 20 years in this church, I have learned that no matter how much debate I hear about the Church, its doctrine, and its leaders, it is NOT about finding logic in the scriptures or theology, it is about what I KNOW, what I have experienced, and what I have learned through the Spirit. Now, call it whatever you want: a chemical reaction in our bodies that makes us feel a certain way. I don't buy it! I have seen the hand of God in my life and I know, without a doubt, that he has guided me to His Church. And even if one day, after dying, I find out I was wrong... oh well, at least right now I'm not lost any more. He's found me!

    I really hope one day soon you find Him too... wherever that may be.

    Til then, please keep on saying hello to me!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Diego,

      I didn't put it in the original post, but I should have. I certainly do not mean in any way to say goodbye to the LDS people I love, nor to anyone at all, especially good friends like yourself.

      I would like to remark that it's not that I am looking for Him, it's that I am looking for an expression of Him. He has never left me.

      We have had different experiences. You say that when people search for something the more they become lost. This experience has taught me otherwise.

      I don't deny your spiritual experience. Nor do I doubt mine.

      All in all thank you for your kind words. If I ever have to serve on a Spanish Branch again, I will only do it if your in the presidency :) Good times.

      By the way, I totally miss going out to the movies with you and the guys. Also good times.

      Delete
  2. Travis,

    I've said it before and I'll say it again - what you have done here takes courage, which is faith. Again, I've never heard of any LDS member doing what you have done here, and I commend your bravery and faithfulness in doing it.

    In the end, and everyday, you are/were more than just a member of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, more than just a blogger about your crisis, you have always been what God has made you, and you and the world have influenced. But you are obviously taking a more active role in what you are and what you are becoming. And that is commendable. That you do it with fear, respect, and honor and love to God is commendable and hopeful.

    I have tried to be a counter-balance to the LDS commentors here. I admit I am not immediately attracted to notes on Crossan and I have little time to read his actual writing, so my activity has been where the LDS activity was. But I, too, am more than just a counter-balance.

    I've enjoyed your posts, even the uncontroversial ones - the kid's song for guilty parents comes to mind. I look forward to your future topics, and their diversity, and your sense of humor.

    I know what you have gone through is not over. I know what you are going through now is not easy. You and yours will remain in mine, my wife's, and even my coworker's prayers.

    I believe you are a believer in Christ and you rely on Him alone for your salvation, and that is a very good end and a very good beginning. May your new beginning bring you closer to the God that Is and may your loved ones respect your choice and honor your willingness to follow Him where He leads.

    May Shalom - Peace - be in you and may the Shalom - Redemption and Flourishing under God - be the fruit of every aspect and everyone in your life.

    In the Name of Jesus the Christ, We pray... Amen.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for your words, Spartacus. I have enjoyed your interjections along with everyone else's contributions. It has been an interesting dialogue to observe and to participate in. I hope to one day meet you. Maybe we can sit down over a cup of joe. Of course, coffee is an acquired taste, so I'll probably get a hot cocoa. Please contact me if you feel like it: trvshumphrey@yahoo.com.

      Delete
  3. I've read this blog for the last couple months and followed it. I enjoyed reading it, it made me look at issues and things of the Church in a point of view that I never have before or will ever be able to. But I am grateful for these honest writings, it meant a great deal to me.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Ah-in-nist sipes, you have a cool name. I am glad you have enjoyed the blog and I hope future posts will be beneficial to you in your faith journey.

    ReplyDelete
  5. "I'm saying hello to the parables, Church history and theology, Greek, unrestrained reading, acceptance of women as my equals in ministry, homosexuals as worthy children of God, and trained church leadership. I'm saying hello to an extremely challenging world that needs more bridges of acceptance than walls of doctrine, dogma, and worries over 'worthiness'. I even say hello to evolution. I am saying hello to a God I don't know, who is mysterious to my imperfect mind and I can admit that and think that's okay. I am saying hello to a faith greater than when I started, wherein the grace of God is more powerful than what I can ever do or not do. I'm saying hello to a Jewish peasant, who taught the Mosaic Law, proclaimed the kingdom, and died on the cross. I say hello to a hope, yes, a hope, that through that man we all can hope in the resurrection and the redemption of creation. Hello"

    You don't have to go very far to greet any of these. You can come say hello at 1506 W Imhoff Rd here in Norman. See ya there.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I agree with Brandon...that IS my church. I guess it is all about perception.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Hey Brandon and Lauri. Thanks for your thoughts.

    I guess I wasn't very specific about the things I see in the church that make me feel both uncomfortable and frustrated. Some of my previous posts really flesh this out. When I see a woman sitting on the stand, serving as a Bishop, Stake President, whatever, then I'll know there has been some major changes of the heart concerning woman in the church. And when I see a homosexual couple able to enjoy the same blessings as a heterosexual couple (i.e. sealing in the temple) then I'll know they are viewed as equal children of God. Right now, it is perception, and I don't perceive equality in diversity. Thanks.

    ReplyDelete
  8. And, since you don't feel any restrictions on reading, I invite you to read Grant H. Palmer's 'Insider's View of Mormon Origins'. Great synopsis of the major issues concerning the LDs historical claims and narrative.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Travis,
    I wish I was a clever, scholarly person.... I'm not. I'm a person who has seen too much and done too much. I'm one of those people for whom meeting missionaries, like you, changed my life. I was on a rough path leading nowhere good. I had grown up a good, Catholic girl with a Catholic heritage of nuns and priests in my family. I lit candles, prayed to the saints for intercession on my behalf. I took communion and even served as a volunteer at the healing center in Lourdes. I prayed for a good, Catholic husband like my grandad. I glorified the sacrifices made by the clergy and I loved the New Testament stories. My crisis of faith came when my mum was excommunicated for divorcing my dad after many years of abuse and philandering. She couldn't take communion or be part of any mass. She had been a card carrying member of the parish for many years and now she was shunned for standing up for herself. I stopped going to mass, started realizing that, historically, the catholic church was a mess!! I knew that God had given up on us. So as the years passed I found alcohol, looked for "love" in all the wrong places, many more things that I don't dwell on anymore. I didn't feel lost. I felt relieved. The burden of God in my life was gone and now I had only humanity to watch me.
    My conversion was not some sudden brightness in a dark place. It was not some feeling of overwhelming love and warmth. It was a slow commitment to a new life. A gentle dawning that, maybe I could have a beacon once again. My husband has a similar story. We have not lived the perfect Mormon life. We have had to force ourselves to church A LOT! Not out of doubt but out of laziness or bad feelings for one another. We have fought ON THE WAY TO CHURCH and turned around, gone home and fought all day.
    What of those people you baptized on your mission? Are you sorry to gave them that hope?
    Are you going to let them know you made a mistake?
    Nobody likes to be told they're wrong but, Travis, those of us who have come into this life from elsewhere know exactly where you are right now, you're just on the opposite(and wrong) side of the fence.
    We should go get lunch one day. I'm at the hospital too nowadays and let me tell you how it really is.
    Much love xox

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Catherine. I appreciate your thoughtful posts. Your cluttering is welcomed, however it will cost you. I always wanted to hear someone with a British accent read a portion of Harry Potter outloud:)

      It's funny how your mother's experience is similar in ways to mine. When my faith crisis hit I voluntarily withdrew from my calling because I didn't want to deceive anyone; I didn't want to be teaching children things I was struggling to believe. I was nonetheless accused of being two-faced. Later, after meeting with my Bishop, I requested to have a calling, any calling. I needed to begin serving people again. Sadly, I never received one. I don't blame the Bishop or anything like that, but I had a screaming spiritual need and I felt ignored, untrusted, shunned. So, I felt a lot like your mother.

      It's funny how you mention the history of the Catholic church. I've been exploring the issues in the LDS history and I have found, what I believe to be, dissapointing revelations concerning its ethics and theological propositions. A few I discussed in earlier posts, but most I never got to. I guess I can bring them up in future posts if that would be helpful.

      I don't think you know where I am, Catherine. I'm happy. I'm at peace. I have been praying fervently for peace in my heart and mind and it has come. At the LDS Church, I don't feel that. I don't say that to mean that no one can feel peace there, of course not. This is my experience and I do not impose it on others. I simply say that I don't find spiritual nourishment there and I don't think anyone should continue in a faith tradition when they are spiritually starving. It doesn't help the faith tradition or the individual.

      I don't regret my mission in the slightest, nor do I feel any embarassment for teaching and baptizing people into the church. I am confident that the people I baptized did so of their on volition. However, as a missionary I knew only the narrative that all missionaries are told to teach, one that lacks historical evidence in places and conveniently leaves out many points of history and theology taught by previous prophets, including teachings and practices of Joseph Smith. I feel it important to teach people the whole story about a religion before asking them to join, including the religiously charged practices of a prophet who engaged in polygamy and polyandry. But I didn't know about these practices on my mission. I taught people what I was told to teach and what I believed was an accuraate depiction of divinely touched history. I trusted in this institution to teach me the truth and it taught me only the parts of history that we like; it taught me a white-washed version of reality. I trusted that white-washed version was true, but on my own searching I have found it is riddled with serious problems. I am sorry, but I feel like the Joseph Smith taught in church is not an accurate portrayal of the actual historical figure.

      I am so glad you have a beacon in your life. I admire you and your family so much. I admire your resolve to make it work no matter what. It's awesome. In my journey I have shed away the tales of a prestine history to find people, real people. People that I don't condemn, just like I no longer condemn the people of the 'great apostacy'. We're all doing our best, and so I would just say that there is no fence unless we build it. I for one am not interested in fences.

      I would love to get together if you would like. I appreciate your concern and this very thoughtful outreach of love. It's much nicer to experience than gossip and accusations.

      Delete
  10. I'm not anonymous, I'm Catherine Richichi!

    ReplyDelete
  11. I'm also not sure this is my last post here. I have a lot more to say. Sorry but I'm warning everyone now.... So you'll know why your email/ Facebook notifications get so cluttered up :)
    Now we can get the niceties out of the way and have a REAL debate

    ReplyDelete